THE WAR THE INFANTRY KNEW 1914 - 1919 (EXCERPT)
[preface] [chapter 9] [chapter
10] [chapter 11]
CHAPTER IX
Somme-Ancre -- Facing Bazentin Ridge -- High Wood
-- Amiens -- Old Army into New -- Moles
Contributors: ARMOUR; BOREHAM; COLTART; CRAWSHAY;
CROCKETT; CROMBIE; FOX; FYSON; HYDE SMITH; C. JONES
('200); MODERA; MOODY; POWELL; RADFORD; ROBERTS; RODERICK; SMITH; T.
SPENS; STOCKWELL
Sketches: 1, 11, I2, 13, I4
[July 7th] The Division goes south: a battalion at Gorre had 20 minutes
notice to be clear of its billets. We were relieved
[July 9th] at 2 o'clock, and marched through Béthune, in the
quiet and freshness of the morning, to Fouquières. In the forenoon
I rode in again, to the Bank. With few troops in it Béthune looked
rather tawdry, even on this perfect summer day. It is a small, rather
drab provincial town, surrounded on three sides by a coal field; its
streets and buildings, even its Gothic remains, are without distinction,
the newer part is formal. The Battles of La Bassée and of Loos,
and the coming and going of resting brigades, cast on it -- for the
B.E.F. -- a passing glamour; and the eleven months we had spent in its
area were to be looked back to with longing by those who lived them
and were to know camps and billets elsewhere.
In the afternoon our late C.O. rode over to see us. His division, after
sharing in the disaster at Serre, has come to convalesce on a quiet
front to the north. He looked as if he would gladly be back with us.
We entrained at midnight, the last unit of the Division to go.
[July 10th] At 7 we arrived at Longueau : 20 officers and 686 other
ranks, a magnificent battalion for its strength, not more than a dozen
unreliables in it. At 8:15 we moved off. The route was through Amiens,
so I slipped away to have a glimpse of the Cathedral. Little of the
detail of the lower storey can be seen because it is protected by sand-bags.
Our march was by Poulainville through rich, boldly rolling country,
a delightful chequer of cultivated, hedgeless fields. The people of
Cardonnette, where we billeted, were shrilly insistent on their "rights".
The rapacious French peasantry is battening on the War, doubly so in
the British zone, and their laborers can't buy sugar or coal on the
paltry two francs paid for a long day. Might one know if the blood of
the Ancre smells sweetest to a French farmer, or a British tradesman,
or an American manufacturer.
[July 11th] Yesterday's march was 6 1/2 miles: today's 4 miles to Daours,
through the same charming country still seen in sunshine. On entering
the village I heard, added to the crunch of many feet on a gritty surface,
the sound of running water, and presently a stream tumbled towards us,
broken over a stony bed. A vision of a Highland glen appeared in the
clear brown water. It was gone in a moment --like the snowflake in the
river, for, raising my eyes to mind my step they rested on an unplaned,
weathered board on which an unskilled hand had painted, "rue napoo".
The pleasing illusion had vanished, but I looked at the water, and listened,
because it was said to be the Ancre. Actually it was a mill-lade; the
river was farther over, and the Ancre farther up the valley. Other village
paths had been named as sardonically -- "verité," "grand
mari" -- by the French troops from whom our Fourth Army had taken
over. We were packed for the night into the top floor of a mill, dear
knows how.
[July 12th] -- At the beginning of an afternoon march of 8 miles up
the right bank of the Ancre we saw Corbie across the Somme. It cold-shouldered
Henry V when he marched along its ridge, to turn at Agincourt on the
host that beset him. Its church looked as if it would repay a visit.
But from what unnamed church nearby did Bardolph take the deceptive
pyx? -- and for the theft be broken on Fortune's furious fickle wheel.
On the road we passed the transport of the Welsh Division coming out
after the mauling at Mametz Wood. Arrived at Buire, we settled into
tents in an orchard. The battle-front is only 7 1/2 miles away, but
not a sound can be heard although the gun-flashes play brightly on the
sky after dark and a big gun must be fairly close. Having come through
the II Corps, we are now in the XV Corps for business; Hone, our G.O.C.
of Loos days, commands it. We are the reserve battalion of the reserve
brigade of its present reserve division.
[July 13th] A body of cavalry passed up when we were at breakfast.
Afterwards the C.O. and Company Commanders went to prospect the forward
area, so we should be "for it" soon. On their return Higginson
wrote to Blair: "You can guess where all good troops are now. I
am enjoying it immensely. This is real war; no burrowing, no wind(1),
no boredom, plenty of marching and changing of scene, and I am splendidly
fit."(2) And Moody wrote: "the whole outfit is splendid."
Mann was ecstatic.
At night the guns became increasingly audible: an atmospheric change.
[July 14th] An early morning drizzle was followed by an hour of heavy
rain beginning at 8 o'clock. "The situation is satisfactory"
is the best that Comic Cuts (3) can say of it. Then why was a cavalry
division sent up yesterday? If only we had no cavalry the operations
might not be spoiled. This is an infantry and artillery war. From all
one hears it is plain that the infantry, "the Queen of Battles",
is being subordinated to the artillery. Fritz has two new well-wired
lines on this front, and it is the conviction of those who have tried
him that he is full of fight.
At 11 o'clock we moved to Méaulte, a squalid, only slightly
damaged village, where we had a haversack lunch: then the whole Brigade
bivouacked on a forward slope one kilometer farther on. On that bit
of the way we passed 900 prisoners, then a smaller party, being marched
down; a major who looked very haughty and resentful was mocked by the
men. At 10, in the dusk, three 5.9 duds fell in the bivouac and one
woolly burst above it. Since the Brigade had been in full view of two
observation balloons, which were still up, no one need have felt surprise.
A new Brigadier had come to us at Buire in place of Robertson, who had
been promoted. He came from his quarters and, running along the lines,
himself told the men to get to the cover of the reverse slope; so the
less disciplined elements of his Command swarmed over anyhow, and the
unsteady ran devil-take-the-hindmost. Comment on the incident was that
the Brigadier deserved better of the change. As the air rarefied, and
the noisy bivouac fell asleep, there arose from the Fricourt road below
us the steady grind of heavy tragic. At midnight it became intermittent,
then it stopped, for the enemy was putting a barrage of large shell
[July 15th] about the road -- 2, 3, and 4 to the minute. Between the
bursts the neighing and snorting of horses and the raised voices of
men came from the valley with singular clearness. This lasted for an
hour, then the shelling ceased and the halted traffic rolled along again.
Brigade reveille. was at 2.30. Kit is reduced to groundsheet and haversack.
At 4 o'clock the Battalion moved down to the Fricourt road through a
duck mist. A few broken wagons, dead horses and drivers -- casualties
of the midnight shelling -- were passed soon after the road was reached.
The soil gave off tear-gas, making eyes and noses run, and spoiling
the taste of tobacco. Ambulances, stragglers, detachments, messengers,
broken guns passed down. A dead German lay on a stretcher by the roadside.
Where the front line of July 1st was crossed we came to ground all pitted
with old and new shell-holes; rifles, equipment, clothing, and the litter
of a recent and an older battlefield strewed it. The villages of Bécordel,
excepting the church tower -- strangely, and Fricourt were flattened.
Beyond Fricourt a detour to the right was made because of a barrage
of 5.9 shell on the road. The march had been interrupted many times,
but at 8 o'clock a halt was ordered and we fell out. Suddenly the mist
cleared, the sun shone down, and we saw that we were among the dead
of the Welsh Division. Friends were recognized, and buried in haste
lest we had to move on. "The cavalry are in Martinpuich",
so said report. The truth, when we got it, was that a squadron had been
sent up to the Bois des Foureaux, "High Wood", hopefully;
it was driven back by heavy fire. The 2nd Queen's, 7th Division, had
occupied a corner of High Wood on the 13th, had failed to advance, and
had been withdrawn. Whether their report was misleading or thoughtlessly
misread, infantry operations were stopped that cavalry night come up
and push through: as if the Germans would not use the respite to mend
any weakness of their position. Now the task of the Division is the
capture of a Switch trench which runs from High Wood to Martinpuich
("Martin's push"). The village is expected to be the Brigade's
morsel.
The attack began at 9 o'clock. Again easy progress was seemingly looked
for. The 100th and 98th Brigades, the latter in echelon on the left,
were sent forward. The first reports were all smiles. Then there was
an uneasy blank. Another short move took us across the road to the south-east
corner of Mametz Wood. The gossip and grouse of time that hangs heavy
began again. A runner going down was asked, "Any news?" "They've
got it in the neck." An understanding look and an unspontaneous
smile passed round, "We'll be for it now." Meanwhile there
was nothing to do but loaf about and seek diversion in small things.
Large letters in white paint on a German gun proclaimed it a trophy
of our 1st Battalion, also in the XV Corps. Our 17th Battalion had claimed
it already in chalk. Two lively Irishmen in our Field Ambulance sent
their Pioneer to claim it in yet larger lettering than Colonel Stockwell's.
In the afternoon Stockwell and others from the 1st Battalion visited
us, and told the bare outline of their doings here, and at Bazentin
Cemetery two days ago: both good Shows. Some of us went, exploring in
Mametz Wood, where the Welsh Division was so mishandled, and there were
nasty sights. A little spasmodic shelling of our area was going on,
harmlessly. Scraps of talk filtered through from 100th Brigade H.Q.,
and from the front. There was angry complaint that our artillery support
was poor and misdirected, and that messages to Division were unheeded.
As the scraps were put together a local disaster took form. The German
guns were splendidly served, the machine-guns were sufficient and artfully
placed. Hidden by the long grass and covering the Switch were new wire
and unreported posts which stopped all progress. Smitten in front and
enfiladed, the two broken brigades ended the day where they began it.
After sunset flights of 0.77 shell twittered over and burst about us
with a quiet plop. My first notion was that the German ammunition was
strangely defective. It was noxious gas-shell, and we were encountering
it for the first time although some had been in use for several months.
Drift gas was no longer used. These shells gave off bromine fumes which
were choking only to anyone who was close to a burst. A few casualties
occurred, so a move forward of 100 yards was made, and we bivouacked
by
[July16th] the roadside. At 1:30 the Argylls, withdrawn from the front,
passed through to bivouac in rear. We became support brigade. We are
assured that "the G.O.C. has the situation well in hand",
and we are promised that officers of the Staff will come up -- from
Fricourt -- to view the scene in daylight. We are duly impressed on
observing how seriously Division takes itself -- at Fricourt.
The night was spent close behind our main artillery position. The noise
was more nearly "ear-splitting" than anything I have known.
A battery of French seventy-fives had taken station at dusk just in
rear. Their high-pitched bark repelled sleep, and attracted the German
artillery, whose overs reached the Indian Cavalry picketed close behind
the French guns. The fine physique of the French gunners was a revelation.
To the noise of their guns and ours had to be added that of ammunition
limbers, an occasional squealing mule, constant shouting, and a frequent
German shell-burst. The 'where' -- no less than the 'how' -- of sleep
baffled me quite, although most of my neighbors solved it. Any shell-hole
or scraping in a bank was a couch, whatever attitude of recumbancy it
imposed. I tried one such scrape for a time; it was too short and narrow
to give even relaxation of muscles: I lay wondering whether a shell,
a limber, a mule or man -- dead or alive -- would fall on me. Some men
seeking "a better 'ole" in the dark, and not seeing that mine
was fully occupied, tried it. Two men dodging a startled mule team stepped,
one on my wind and one just not on my face. After that I sat down in
the open and longed for day. One of our Sapper officers slept beside
a several-days-old corpse without noticing any unpleasantness. All about
us the air was heavy with the reek of the dead in Mametz Wood.
In the morning the Brigade transport, which had followed us, was sent
away, but Yates chose to keep ours where it was. Throughout the day
batteries rolled into the Happy Valley, the prosaic called it the Valley
of Death, east of Mametz Wood, and on to the slight rise of Caterpillar
Wood until these sites were stiff not with guns but with batteries.
"The shelling on both sides is, tremendous," Higginson wrote
to Blair, "but nobody worries. Whole brigades sit down en masse
in a field, and we bivouac in close order every night. The whole show
is in the open; guns and all. Think of us, in your nice white bed with
beautiful Sisters floating round. I sleep in my burberry, and we are
down to bully, biscuits, etc." Rain came on in the afternoon.
[July 17th] The rain and the noise lasted all night. H.Q., which alone
had any shelter, occupied a warren of joined-up shell-holes roofed with
shell-punctured iron sheets, through which the rain dripped or streamed
to the sodden ground on which we sat or lay. The sun came with day.
Ground and wet clothing dried. Orders and counter-orders arrived. There
was nothing to do but watch the guns beside us in action and the enemy's
counter-battery. Again and again the gunners were driven to cover, and
guns were disabled; once the tire of a wheel went spinning 20 or 30
feet into the air. The German gunners could not have shot better over
open sights. There was a story next day of an observer with signaling
gear having been found up a tree in Bazentin Wood. The overs were few,
but they caused us some casualties. Our total so far was 5 killed and
21 wounded; 2 or 3 of the latter were bromine gas cases. In the afternoon
G.1 came among us, charged with another official platitude, "The
morale of the Division is unimpaired" : a sure index of failure
and loss.
The Division was relieving the 21st Division north of Bazentin-le-Petit;
it had already relieved the 7th in the village Cemetery. At midnight
the Battalion moved through a light barrage of explosive and bromine
shells to relieve the 4th King's between the Cemetery and the Martinpuich
road. A corporal had been sent to guide D Company to the Cemetery. "The
blighter lost his way," says the C.S.M., "and my language
quite shocked such a hardened sinner as von R. Graves." There were
a few casualties
[July 18th] going up. The night was noisy and wet, the morning quiet
and fine. An appalling lot of our dead strewed the easy rise of the
High Wood-Martinpuich glacis. Towards midday a gunner subaltern galloped
up a gun-team, hooked in an abandoned German gun which no infantry seemed
to lay claim to, and galloped away with it. His men, who had never been
so near the front, looked as if they thought the earth would open and
swallow them. For four hours of the afternoon our position was under
a bombardment that caused losses in which H.Q. Details shared largely.
One of the first to be wounded was a sergeant. I turned at the sound
of a coming shell and saw it burst. Almost at the same moment he shouted,
"I'm hit," in a joyful tone, flung off his equipment, and,
grinning, came to me for his "ticket to Blighty, sir." It
didn't occur to him to have the wound in his back looked at. We had
5 killed and 32 wounded during the day. Dinner was prepared for the
C.O. in a deep cemented "dug-out" the servants discovered.
Our stomachs turned at food which had been left unfinished before search
showed that the floor was removable; it was the lid of a cesspool. After
dark the Battalion side-stepped to the right. "Hordes of rats came
over D Company's ground. They made a noise like wind through corn. It
was uncanny."
[July 19th] There was rain most of the night. For the first time since
the night of the 13th I slept for more than an occasional snatch of
a few minutes: had a real good sleep, swathed in silk brocade curtains.
Two large and very substantially built dug-outs had been found in an
Engineers yard. They were furnished with the spoil of some opulent house.
All the work in this German yard was thorough, it had the solidity and
finish of permanent work. There was reinforced glass in the workshop
windows, and in the frames and hot-house of a well-cultivated kitchen
garden the like of which I never saw anywhere else in France. The day
was fine. There was more activity in the air than usual. We watched
the superiority of our airmen with much satisfaction, for the Germans
had been having the best of it of late. The Battalion had a quiet, easeful
day after several days of physical discomfort and broken sleep, of the
exhaustion of mere drawn-out waiting, of being amid almost incessant
noise, and of suffering appreciable losses. In all, 10 had been killed
and 53 wounded so far.
An early morning operation tomorrow is substituted for yesterday's
cancelled night operation against High Wood. It looks like "the
goods" this time. High Wood is about a mile east and north of Bazentin-le-Petit,
at the waist of a tactically important ridge which it would be good
to bestride. The Wood is roughly diamond-shaped with the angles to the
cardinal points. Its western angle and the adjoining westerly, and slightly
higher, ground was organized as a strong-point to which the partly sunken
road to Flers, bounding the north-west side of the Wood, gave the Germans
their simplest access. An incomplete trench ran through the Wood from
the middle of the north-east side to the Point; it was part of the Delville
("Devil's") Wood-High Wood-Martinpuich Switch. The 800-yard
south-west face of the Wood was to be attacked by the 5th Scottish Rifles
and The Cameronians, the latter taking on the strong-point. The 20th
Royal Fusiliers were to support the attack, follow the 5th S.R., and,
pivoting on their own left, mop up the Wood from east to west. The 11th
Field Company R.E, was to be at hand for the making of strong-points
at the east, north, and west angles. Our approaches are over open ground
that rises, in two long shallow billows, to about 60 feet above the
Longueval-Contalmaison road. The 7th Division, on the right, and the
5th beyond it, would attack Black Road and Wood Lane at the same time.
These were entrenched cart-tracks running from the southern and eastern
corners of High Wood to Longueval. The 2nd Worcesters were to cover
the left of the Brigade's assembly, but once the advance began the left
flank would be open. Such in barest outline was the problem, and the
scheme of a Corps operation.
By midnight the units of the Brigade were moving to their assembly
[July 20th] positions. The Battalion was relieved amid confusion, and
held in reserve among the shell-holes between the Longueval-Contalmaison
road and Flat Iron Copse. Any exit from the Happy Valley was usually
a busy traffic route, so our position was an obvious barrage area. All
night the Germans dropped crumps about it. Our massed artillery was
behind us; H.Q. and its Details were under the muzzles of two batteries.
In the dark hours guns fired. Not even youth could sleep; from zero,
3.30, for what seemed a long time we had to shout to be heard. For hour
after hour of daylight guns fired. The crumping of the area increased,
but the Companies suffered little. That was largely because so many
men were detached for Brigade carrying-duty between the dumps at Montauban
and the front. Traffic, perhaps fortunately, was nearly all through
Montauban. During these hours little happened to interest the rest of
us. A man was walking along the Contalmaison road when a 5.9 burst beside
him; out of the smoke and dust he was flung in a series of somersaults,
just like a rabbit shot when at full stretch: like the shot rabbit he
lay all of a limp heap. Another 5.9 tossed D Company's officers, sending
Nigel Parry to hospital to lose an eye. They moved. About 10 o'clock
there was more commotion among them after a fresh burst. When Barkie
detached himself Mann said, "He's coming for you, Doctor."
We laughed quietly at the quaintness of his stooping gait, straddling
as he ran; it was the agile man's usual run over shell-pocked ground
under fire. Graves had a bad chest wound of the
kind that few recover from. And so, while we just waited on events and
orders, the hours sped.(1)
The events on which our orders would depend were taking place about
a mile, as the crow flies, to our right front, on top of the slope that
rose before us. We could not see anything of them, and no news or rumor
came our way; but without a knowledge of these events an account of
our later concerns would be meaningless. When the attacking troops were
moving in artillery formation from their assembly position to their
line of deployment the German barrage fell on the middle of the column.
The casualties were mostly among the 20th R.F. -- two score or so of
whom thereupon fell back to the cover of the roadside ditch -and the
Sappers. On the right: as the Wood was approached the German barrage
was nasty but there was no rifle or machine-gun fire. Proceedings, however,
became confused, the assault troops and their supports got all mixed
up, and thus 5th S.R. and 20th R.F. pushed through to the other side
of the Wood; any who went beyond it were fired on from farther forward,
where there was a strip of trees. About a dozen Germans had been captured
in an abandoned gun-emplacement: others had been seen bolting back to
a trench, the Switch, outside the Wood. Parties of both battalions began
to dig along the boundary hedge on the far side. There was scarcely
any firing then: the Gordons, on the right; were moving about in the
open. After it became light, however, a lot of rifle and machine-gun
fire developed, inflicting loss. On the left: The Cameronians right
half-battalion came under small-arms fire, but it pushed through to
its objective, the far side, without much loss. The left half-battalion
was held up by heavy small-arms fire from the edge of the Wood, some
riflemen were up trees, and by machine-guns farther to the left. Trench-mortars
were sent for to cope with the machine-guns, and they did good work
in knocking them out. Upwards of two hours elapsed before The Cameronians,
with R.F. cooperation, drove the Germans from their strong-point. Dead
and wounded of both these battalions lay in the Flers road. It is doubtful
if the strong-point was actually occupied, owing to the fire poured
into it from farther west, but The Cameronians and the Germans denied
it to each other. The north of the Wood was still in enemy possession,
so the Acting O.C. Cameronians asked for reinforcements. By that time
men of all three battalions were mixed in the middle of the Wood. German
shelling, which had been on its approaches, had shortened on to it;
and our guns were firing a lot of shorts(4) into it. As the morning
advanced German small arms fire from three directions became more active.
There was a wide drive the Germans had used for vehicles, that ran from
side to side east of the middle of the Wood; it was littered with bodies;
some of them were from an earlier attack (that by the 2nd Queen's).
Anyone entering that drive was fired on. Casualties mounted up everywhere:
officers became fewer; men fell back singly and in small parties to
the lee side. "From quite early the unfortunate R.F. men seemed
to be getting killed all over the place to no purpose. The whole operation
had been conducted in confusion almost from the start, and for want
of superior direction it became a shambles." (The foregoing paragraph
has been written from statements by Royal Fusiliers, Cameronians, and
Scottish Riflemen.)
The C.O. became impatient in the absence of news, so he sent Conning
and Sergeant Roderick forward to learn what had happened. Soon afterwards,
getting on for 9 o'clock, he had a message from Brigade saying that
nothing [recent] of the situation was known there, asking if he knew
anything, and suggesting that he send to find out. About an hour later
the O.C. 20th R.F. was seen coming along the road, wounded. He was intercepted.
After summarizing the situation he added, in a torrent of ejaculations,
that nothing was being done; everything was chaotic; no one was in command;
not a reply to a message, not an order, had been received from Brigade.
When the C.O. had recovered his breath he suggested to Colonel Bennett
to call at Brigade before going to the Dressing-station: but this he
did not do.
The passing. of messages, assuming they were sent, between front and
rear was always a difficulty, and a vexation at both ends. Before the
action Radford had been asked for by Brigade to be employed as Forward
Liaison Officer. He was detailed with some signalers to use Bazentin-le-Petit
Windmill, 200 yards east of the Cemetery, as the forward post of a relay
system. The Windmill had been the target of our artillery, then of the
enemy's as the Germans and then we occupied it. It had been mostly destroyed
during the week. Being near the village and the Longueval-Bazentin road
it was bombarded at every period of enemy activity. "At the beginning
of the morning attack the enemy barrage cut the wires. The barrage smoke
made lamp signaling impossible, even if adequate preparations had been
made for it. The wireless set provided was for transmission only so
it was not known if messages were being received. The supply of runners
was soon exhausted and was not replaced. At noon I went to Brigade to
report the futility of it all." (Radford). Brigade was in poor
quarters, a thinly roofed trench in the south-east bight of Mametz Wood,
nearly two miles from High Wood, although deep and roomy dug-outs made
for a German division were in Bazentin-le-Petit within a few yards of
screened view-points from which the face of High Wood and the Flers
road could be seen. Advanced Brigade, so-called, in the quarry by the
Cemetery, roadside, was a mere relay post. This remoteness was laid
down in a General Routine Order, issued because of casualties earlier
in the War. The Order was circumvented by Brigadiers who knew when and
how to do it, but times without number it warranted the utter negation
of Command when prompt and authoritative decision was needed, especially
if more than one unit was concerned. Prompt decision and action were
essential this day, 'yet none of our Brigade Staff came within hundreds
of yards of its dissolving units.' The cost in all the lower ranks of
preserving some Generals of brigade and division, and some members of
their Staff's, is beyond reckoning, but must be stupendous.
About 11 o'clock the situation in front changed suddenly. A confused
mob of all units fell back on the southern side and made for the open.
The Second-in-Command of the 5th S.R. was one of the officers and N.C.O.s
who rallied them; he met them as he was coming over from Advanced Brigade,
having been sent for when his C.O. was wounded early in the morning.
A line was re-formed upwards of 200 yards from the southern corner.
The Germans had counter-attacked and recovered their western strongpoint,
but they did not penetrate the Wood elsewhere, or to any depth there.
Nothing was known about it half an hour later to a R.F. party whom one
of their officers found on the north-east side, to the left of the fatal
drive, and recalled. The newly-come O.C. 5th S.R. was killed when he
was reconnoitering with a view to recovering abandoned ground. (This
paragraph is from R.F. and Scottish sources).
An Order to complete the capture of High Wood was delivered at H.Q.,
also about 11 o'clock. Said to have been issued by Division at 8 o'clock,
it was seemingly a compliance with the Cameronian early morning call
for reinforcement. Company Commanders where summoned to H.Q. for orders
and instructions. Conning and Sergeant Roderick arrived with them to
help at the talk; they had little to tell except of confusion, and that
no one could say much about the situation. The Wood was to be mopped
up from east to west. Dispositions were simple: the C.O. added that
no obstacle was to cause delay.
A large part of the Battalion was still on fatigue. Little time was
needed to fall-in the small body that remained. The perfect steadiness
with which the weak Companies formed up on the shelled road was a stirring
sight. They marched off in columns of platoons in fours, later in file,
at 100 yards interval. Moody led D Company, followed by B, C, and A.
"The day was bright, the sun was high, and I was pleased to be
moving. Colonel Crawshay and Mr. Mann stood on the left of the road
(near the Blasted Tree) and cheered our happy band of about eight men,
which comprised the whole of No. 8 Platoon.' (Roderick) Of the full
mile to be covered more than half was in a howitzer barrage line. Good
though the shooting was it caused neither check nor disorder. Two or
three shocked men dropped out: a shell bursting on a section ended it:
casualties, however, still were remarkably few. Near Crucifix Corner,
before we turned left off the Longueval-Bazentin road, the jovial R.C.
Chaplain, McShane, chaffed and cheered us. He had assumed virtual command
of the R.F. fainéants there. As the Wood was approached the Intelligence
Officer of the 5th S.R., being carried down wounded, was met and questioned,
but still the enemy's dispositions remained a mystery to us. Elements
of the entire Brigade were seen lying mingled half-way along the southwest
side. Part of A and B Companies' carrying-parties were there; they rejoined
their Companies. A feeble 5th S.R. company in the eastern angle was
the only organized body any of us saw. Moody and two of his subalterns
went into the Wood at once to reconnoiter. They had gone beyond where
some 20th R.F.'s were, upwards of 200 yards, and learned very little,
when Moody was hit in the foot and Barkworth through the cheek. Meanwhile
D Company, waiting for the others to come up, was sheltering from machine-gun
fire from its near front, and long-range fire from its right or right
rear. D, B, and C were deploying along the south-east side of the Wood,
with two platoons of A in close support. They were in three columns
of three lines each. 'Waiting to attack is like what waiting for the
hangman to come and do his job must be. Everyone is eager to get going,
one way or the other, for the uncertainty of being launched into eternity
or of coming back in pieces is not comforting in these tense moments,
but once the button is pressed and the machinery set working all such
thoughts are dispelled." (Roderick) By 2 o'clock all were ready.
Few of us can credit the flight of three hours since the first stirring
of this adventure.
"It was the quietest part of the day in my corner of the Wood
when I heard movement behind me, and saw Moody forming up his Company.
These Welch Fusiliers were a magnificent sight. They were very weak,
their platoons were only the size of sections, but they were out for
business. This small controlled force was a most effective contrast
to the large loose mass that had been herded into the Wood in the morning,
when one attacking battalion and one in support, not mixed with it,
would have been ample. Immediately after the Welch Fusiliers had all
formed up (their C.O. ordered the advance). They were obviously out
for blood, and were most heartening. The platoon sergeant(5) of their
right platoon was shepherding his men like a mother, picking up spades,
ammunition and anything likely to be useful." (Coltart)
The going was not bad just at the start; but the luxuriant July foliage
on the low-hanging. and broken branches, and fallen beech trees, --the
result of ten days' shelling -- made keeping any sort of alignment or
direction more and more difficult.
"Beyond the 20th R.F. Details was Sergeant Hinder and his Vickers
gun. He was one of ours who, along with his team, had been transferred
to the Machine Gun Corps. I was going on by myself when I came on him.
He said, 'For God's sake, don't go on, the place is full of Gerries.'"
(Roderick). Roderick, however, went on ahead of his Company, B, until
he arrived on a road outside the Wood without seeing a German. "After
looking north I turned south and saw a machine-gun in a T-sap across
the road. It let me have a burst, two bullets in the forearm and pieces
in the thigh; I found afterwards that a bullet had broken up on the
Verey pistol in my pocket. Naturally I made back for the Wood. The Battalion
had been held up and was advancing again, but my chapter of the War
in France was ended."
A machine-gun which D Company had been feeling since their arrival
gave a lot of trouble. They lost another officer, Crockett, and were
held up. The gun was spotted near the middle of the north side, in a
trench without the Wood. Sergeant '200 Jones turned Corporal Shearsby's
section of his platoon half-right. "They silenced it' -- is all
I have been able to learn of the incident. The Company barged forward
again in rushes from cover to cover such as tree-trunks and shell-holes.
In the middle of the Wood the artillery of both sides had to be faced,
for the Germans were putting shells into it and our guns were still
firing short. Small-arms fire was more and more met as the Companies
advanced. A's platoons had closed up on B. C Company, on the left, had
passed parties of the other battalions. All were converging on the western
corner whence a deadly fire came, but they thrust forward without counting
the cost. D Company's last officer fell wounded in a bit of trench near
the far side of the Wood. He saw his men "pass on in a hopeless
mix-up, bombing and firing at very close range". (Roberts) The
C.O., standing near H.Q. at the southern corner, saw a lot of Germans
bolt from the Wood to the open beyond the Flers road. Not long afterwards
a message informed him that the Wood had been captured. '200 Jones,
however, reported that the right of D Company was held up 80 yards short
of their objective, and that they were too few to push forward farther
against the volume of fire coming from their front. He was told to dig-in:
that was as far as his platoon got. The C.O. made a short tour of inspection,
and sent Higginson up to order the Companies to make the western corner
secure. The shelling had ceased by then.
Soon after the C.O. launched the attack a Brigade Order arrived appointing
him "O.C. High Wood." The other units were thereupon told
of the attack in progress, and the Trench Mortar Battery was called
on to cooperate -- it did not, however, fire during the operation, or
any more that day; the subsequent cooperation of all units in consolidating
was detailed: "everybody must work at high pressure". Until
the arrival of an amending Order the 20th R.F. were not included in
his authority. In the interval the officer on whom their command had
devolved entrenched himself in the Army List. "I am sainior to
Major Cra'shay," he reiterated, and sat tight; and he let his men
at Crucifix Corner sit tight.
When approximate casualty reports were made up it was found that 150
of all ranks of the small number in action had been killed or wounded.
Every officer who took part in the attack was a casualty. Heastey, the
last of the likeable gallant trio of youngsters who joined from Sandhurst
in June, was killed: at night his platoon carried him back two miles
for burial. Bowles, who came home from Argentina to serve, was brought
out smiling, dying. As O.C. High Wood the C.O. was dismayed on learning
that the other units were in no better case than we. The Cameronians
had lost their Adjutant, all four company commanders and eight other
officers, and a great many rank and file. The 5th S.R had only one officer
left. The R.F, were disorganized; their losses were nearly two-thirds
of the strength with which they began the day. Few Engineers were left;
they had no wire and scarcely any other stores. The bulk of the men
were enlisted "for the duration", or were Territorials; being
without leaders they were a difficult lot to get started on work. In
these circumstances Brigade was advised that fresh troops should relieve
those on the ground if the holding of the Wood was to be reasonably
assured.
Roberts is mentions "a flare-up like a counter-attack by the Germans"
on their lost strong-point about 3 o'clock. Some Cameronians joined
in the affray, during which a small party of Germans ran from among
the trees on the left and escaped into the Flers road. Of the 5 he saw,
one, in passing, had a shot at him as he lay. Nothing of the affair
was seen by the right of his Company. It is not unlikely that it arose
from Germans who had been cut off making a dash for their own side.
Apart from that the Wood was a peaceful spot for a couple of hours,
cool to walk in on a rather airless afternoon. One could step clear
of its north-eastern side with impunity, and at the north end of the
beech hedge bounding the Flers road one could stand in gaps apparently
unseen, certainly not fired at. But from Delville Wood the enemy kept
up a dropping long-range machine-gun fire on the south-east side and
southern corner. Exposure near the western corner was apt to draw fire
from across the Flers road: perhaps because there was no officer among
them earlier our men were not dug into effective possession there. Meanwhile
all our working-parties and the Sapping Platoon had rejoined, providing
a much-needed reinforcement, and an officer became available for each
Company. Chaos had been lessened, and a start was being made with work.
Some time about 5 o'clock the original defense scheme was superseded
by an Order to dig and wire a trench running diagonally across the Wood
to face the German Switch. The Order to the Battalion to complete the
capture of the Wood had been issued by Division, or higher authority,
before the successful German counter-attack was made. We never heard
what was known behind of the situation when this latest Order was issued.
The new line simplified the work to be done, but we on the spot were
concerned at handing back to the enemy his strong-point at the western
angle and the Flers road that gave entry to it, the only parts of the
Wood by which he seemed to set much store. An hour or more later the
G.S.0.2 came to H.Q. and explained that the reduction of the ground
to be held was because of the machine-guns across the Flers road. To
us it seemed that an extravagance of effort had been asked for in ordering,
twice, the assault, and capture of a position it was imprudent to hold
or deny to the enemy. Had not the whereabout and strength of that armament
been known since the disaster to the 100th and 98th Brigades a week
earlier? Yet an effectual means of dealing with these machine-guns had
no place in the scheme of either of the day's attacks. Nothing, however,
was so maddening as his parting remark, "the General has the situation
in hand" -- spoken with a straight face. The situation never was
grasped. Fumbling fingers far away had trifled with opportunity for
hours; and days ago a hopeful infantry advance was stopped that cavalry
might be brought up. Now, before our Companies were withdrawn, all was
quiet across the Flers road. A R.F. sergeant-major, Armour (of The Cameronians),
entered the road, although our men protested that he would draw fire,
and walked leisurely round the corner without being fired at.
A fresh start was made. The digging and manning of the new line was
divided between D Company, to which Conning was transferred, and B,
Coster's -- about 70 all told, on the right; and two R.F. companies,
actually elements of all their companies, on the left. Sergeant '10
Jones's attenuated platoon occupied a bit of the Switch as our covering-party.
There was a machine-gun where the two battalions joined and one on each
flank. A. Company, Higginson's, and C, having Moulsdale Williams in
temporary command, were withdrawn to support; H.Q. and they occupied
and improved 150 yards of Black Road. The 2nd Gordons continued this
line to the right. Elements of the rest of the Brigade still lay mingled
along the south-west of the Wood; the 5th S.R. company was in the eastern
corner; and there were overlooked oddments inside, but that detail was
learned later.
The day had been warm and still with a slight haze, the evening was
serene. The escorts of our Air observers and the German fliers met over
the Wood, and regaled us with some great art as they maneuvered and
fought. The trees masked much of it from us, but our 1st Battalion at
Bazentin-le-Grand saw it all. About 8 of our slow planes were patrolling,
or spotting for guns, when two Fokkers appeared. One of them marked
down a spotter, and had driven it almost to the ground when one of the
escort came to its help, and the Fokker fled. A few minutes later a
Fokker pounced on another of ours, like a hawk on a bird; the bird,
turning and twisting to escape, was being forced always farther down.
Our plane was down to about 300 feet when one of the escort rushed to
its rescue in a swoop of about 3000 feet. The Fokker gave up its quarry
-- which went off groggily, -- swerved and tried to mount, but our fighter
was too quick for it. A Lewis gun rapped out short, sharp bursts. Then
the Fokker came evenly over us, at only 300 feet, with seemingly splendid
bravado, but it was out of control: the pilot had been hit. Our fighter
left it to its fate. As it glided slowly over Bazentin Cemetery the
troops there fired at it: when above Bazentin-le-Petit Wood it crashed
and burst into flames, and a great cheer went up behind. It was a splendid
fight, both sides. Guns and all stopped while everyone stood agape.
Shelling by the Germans had begun again before this; intermittent for
a time, it became continuous although not at all heavy, and our answering
guns fired short so often. A good deal of movement was seen on the right
front beyond the Flers road; if the information about it that was sent
back reached the artillery no action was taken. Between 7 and 8 o'clock
the Sapper officer inspected the new line. He reported to the C.O. that
D and B Companies had dug a good trench, but that the R.F. had made
very uneven progress; in parts they were down only 6 inches and there
was barely cover anywhere. Manual labor was distasteful to them, and
was not seriously enforced, for they were officered from their own ranks.
The trench did not then follow the line of one dug later at more leisure;
it began on the north-east side and ran diagonally across the Wood;
near its middle a short piece of earlier, probably German, trench was
used.
That the enemy had taken heart of grace, and was closing on the dearly
bought ground that had been handed back to him, was apparent after sunset.
What looked like a ration-party came up in the direction of the strong-point.
Soon afterwards a solitary German strolled across the open towards D
Company's right flank. Someone shot him, unaware that others hoped to
take him for what he might tell. By this time any detected movement
by our covering-party drew such accurate small-arms fire from the west
that they were glued to the ground. Since that fire increased until
it became continuous the party rejoined its Company when the light faded
among the trees. The small-arms fire ceased after that, and there was
a short time of quiet. Next, the Germans started a heavy creeping barrage
eastwards through the Wood. It stopped short of the trench and lifted
on to the communications.(6) The R.F. were feeling comforted at the
lifting of the guns when a mixed party of their men, Cameronians and
5th S.R., about 20 altogether, drifted in from the front, past the center
machine-gun, shouting excitedly, "He's coming over." They
were not demoralized, just leaderless. A R.F. officer had no difficulty
in stopping them and bringing them back. He was shot just after doing
so. The R.F.s belonged to some posts which had been overlooked. Their
H.Q. promptly informed the C.O. that their line, or outpost line, had
been rushed and that an attack was developing. It was then about 9 o'clock.
No connected account of the bush-melee in which D and B Companies became
involved was ever given me, or any real detail of what happened to B,
by those who could have told most. Statements made then, and much later,
agree that not a few of them failed to connect the sudden coming of
loose bodies of Germans on to their front with an intended attack, consequently
it had much of the advantage of surprise. "A strong body of Germans
appeared advancing without formation or apparent leadership towards
D Company's right. (They came through the Wood from the direction of
the Flers road.) It looked as if they were going to give themselves
up when they started firing, and we replied. Sergeant Hinder, who was
on the Company's flank, ran forward, clear of the Wood, with his machine-gun
to try to enfilade them; the wonder is he wasn't killed or captured.
Feeling we were outnumbered I ordered the men with me to retire to the
edge of the Wood. I had exhausted my own bombs, to good effect I think,
when I had to jump quick and beat it as a German aimed at me point-blank
and fired." (Powell). One of our wounded, -whether of B or D cannot
be learned, told a R.F. stretcher-bearer who dressed him that a party
of Germans came over with the seeming intention of surrendering, but
on getting within bombing distance they began to sling bombs which they
had been carrying hung behind them. "The Welch quickly stopped
them" can refer only to a temporary check. No one knew what was
happening beyond a very limited circle of himself. Some men lost their
heads and fell back, and could not be recalled by their N.C.O.s. That
night Conning told how he had tried to pivot his broken Company and
maintain a fighting front. Of B Company, it was said at the time that
rifle-fire at close range was opened on them, and the attackers closed
quickly to bombing range, and that they had to fight on front and rear.
C.S.M. Miners, a most dutiful soldier, and half the remnant of the Company
became casualties. Coster, a stout, level-headed officer, got away with
the residue when they were being rolled up. The right of the R.F.s "heard
the Germans coming through the Wood from a north-westerly direction,
but none were seen. The men were ordered to fire in the direction of
the sounds, and fire was opened among the trees." "The Vickers
gun in the center was trained on the direction of the sounds, but it
did not fire, it could not do so for fear of hitting the Welsh."
Singly and in twos and threes men of ours came back, clear of the Wood
behind the strong-point at the eastern angle, and a machine-gun took
position there. In the dim light that blurred their forms they were
looked on with suspicion when first they were seen, and were not being
fired on from Wood Lane or the Switch; but the support Companies were
steady enough not to fire. There came to be such a jumble at the edge
of the Wood that it was not easy to sort out the two Companies again.
Nothing was heard by the C.O. from Conning or Coster, or of them, until
they had time to report in person at the end of the affair.
The Germans had reoccupied the Wood up to the Switch; then they made
a left-hand drive of the ground in front of it, and attacked our part
of the Brigade line. By 10 o'clock they had mopped up a dozen unwounded
prisoners of the Brigade. The last to be taken, the witness to these
details, was a 5th S.R. lance-corporal who had spent the whole day lying
among dead and severely wounded men in a 'gun-pit' beside the traffic
gap on the north-east side. His companions were mostly victims of the
machine-gun that fired through the gap. From daylight, for hours, men
and groups who entered the ride along which it fired had been shot down.
Very soon after all was over a fresh Engineer company arrived with
wire and other stores that had been wanting since morning; and the Divisional
Labour Battalion came to dig a communication trench. But an inept Command
had let the unforgiving hours go by, bearing opportunity with them.
When O.C. Labour heard of the altered situation he marched his battalion
down again, although the need for a communication trench was greater
than when he was sent up. The only fresh troops who might have been
used for action were our ration-party under R.Q.M.S. Boreham, and 98
drafts he had brought up; they were all kept as a reinforcement. It
was not understood when renewed action was under consideration that
the R.F. part of the line was intact until a subordinate officer withdrew
his men on hearing . that the Labour lot had arrived. Anyhow, a night
attack on an unlocated enemy in a wood was not undertaken. And at 10
o'clock the Germans began a bombardment so merciless that any attempted
operation would have been vain. "They plastered the Wood with heavies,
machine-guns, and what appeared to be most of the guns on the Somme.
This lasted for an hour or more."
The hours of darkness were a time of strained suspense. The experiences
of seven such days and nights as had been ours, and the chagrin at the
end of them, made nerves susceptible to trivial impressions. A large
shell coming from the right rear at intervals and bursting beside the
right of the Battalion was, in fact, the only disturbance, but it caused
intense exasperation because it looked as if one of our own guns was
firing short. We learned two days later that it came from a German enfilade
gun at Combles. At
[July 2lst] 1:30 two companies of the 1st Queen's and one of the16th
K.R.R.C. appeared unexpectedly and announced our relief. To change over
was an affair of minutes. The difficulty of communicating with Brigade
continued to the end. Battalion runners had been very unlucky in the
barrage: as we went out the last of them to be sent, a corporal of the
Signals, was found at the side of a track, wounded in both legs. When
we passed through the Happy Valley it was quite silent for the first
time since our coming a week ago.
Arrived at our bivouac on the south-east of Mametz Wood, some, even
of the hard-bitten, showed signs of the strain through which they had
passed now there was no more need to key themselves up. Everyone lay
down where he found himself and slept, though the imaginative shouted,
cried horrors, and gesticulated in their sleep.
The morning and early afternoon were spent in peace and quiet, cleaning
up, and resting in the warm sunshine. Our casualties
yesterday were 2 officers and 29 other ranks killed, 9 officers and
I80 other ranks wounded, 29 other ranks missing. Many of the missing
were of B Company, the result of the German counter-attack at dark.
D Company began the day with 4 officers and 101 other ranks, there were
43 other ranks on relief. One of those wounded at night escaped capture,
and crawled out two days later; he wrote from hospital that the Germans
behaved well in collecting the wounded. A German N.C.O. was in charge
of the left-hand mop-up. He marched the unwounded prisoners of the Brigade
to the rear. About two miles back he halted them at a canteen, went
in and bought a box of cigarettes and a bottle of brandy; each prisoner
was given six or seven cigarettes and a pull at the bottle.
Our disappointment was great that what had been gained so dearly had
been lost so supinely. Weakness behind us had ruled the day, but our
Companies ought not to have been deceived by the appearance of the oncoming
Germans at dusk. Many of us had never seen Germans attacking; those
who had seen them had forgotten that they ambled forward in a purposeless-like
way, in a very loose line however open the ground; and it was not known,
or forgotten, that the German stick-bomb was carried hooked to the back
of the belt. The surprise apart, "duration" men felt themselves
helpless without bombs to reply to bombs; even the Old Army's ready
dependence on the rifle had yielded to the cult of the bomb, and few
of our men had one left since the afternoon.
About 3 o'clock the Battalion and its Transport marched to Buire. We
passed the 5lst Division going up: they were a fine body of men, although
the kilt is a costume that flatters. Our Division was coming out. By
holding the south-east of the Wood the net gain of its costly operations
was the High Wood approach, from which Corps or Army withdrew the 7th
Division eight days ago to give the cavalry a run.
[July 23rd] A Divisional Order pats its own back enthusiastically.
The full flavor of it is only for those who know that an acrimonious
quarrel rages between Division and Corps. Each blames the other for
the recent mismanagement. The affair has gone to Army.
[Judy 24th] Corps, now the 5th, 51st, and 19th Divisions, is said to
have failed again dismally against the Delville-High Wood Switch. --
Our camp is a pleasant, restful place by a musical stream with the tones
of a rocky bottom, and birches overhanging its steep verdure-clad banks.
The excitable have ceased to call out in their sleep.
[July 25th] At Corbie : a large party of newly captured Germans, a
fine body of men, marched by in sullen pride. The church is
[July 27th]. heavy, cold, uninspiring. Albert, the Encre of Agincourt
days, is a very ordinary little industrial town: if the Cathedral had
been destroyed nothing of value would have been lost.
[July 28th] Inspected by the Brigadier. We looked quite passable: if
only we were so in fact. How superficial and farcical such inspections
are!
This was the hardest-worked rest I remember. The quality of the drafts
made those of us who were used to a different personnel fearful of the
immediate future, so every working hour was given to trying to get them
into some sort of shape. We made up with 540 of all ranks. Whether Volunteers,
Derbyites or Conscripts, the average physique was good enough, but the
total included an astonishing number of men whose narrow or misshapen
chests, and other deformities or defects, unfitted them to stay the
more exacting requirements of service in the field. Permission to send
back a very few was accompanied by a peremptory intimation that a complaint
of any future draft passed by the Base would not be listened to. Route-marching,
not routine tours of trench duty, made recurring temporary casualties
of these men. The truly disquieting fact about the drafts was that a
large number had been attested only six weeks before they came to us,
so unready had the War Office been to replace losses properly. What
was called training hardly amounted to a "lick and a promise",
it did not fit the men to take part in any operation. They had fired
only five rounds of ball cartridge; many of them did not know how to
load and unload a rifle, to fix and unfix a bayonet. Hitherto training
in the Battalion had been the pursuit of specialists or a formality,
now it was a matter of H.Q. anxiety and arduous company detail. Men
recruited and trained for the Cheshires, Shropshires, and South Wales
Borderers arrived resentful of their transfer and unwanted by us. There
was a like mix-up in the other battalions of the Brigade. At the time
we thought it was owing to confusion at the Base, and incompetence beyond
understanding. A rumor, which time proved to be true, was dismissed
as a silly joke. Some hairy-eared theorist, in whom the new War Lord
trusted, had told him that the way to win was to destroy the Regiment,
the immemorial foundation of armies, and nationalize the Army. Roger
Poore, who came to us the following year, was commanding a second-line
draft-finding unit at home. He told how, in answer to questions at an
inspection, he gave his reasons for certain of his methods of training.
At a point of his tour the inspector said, "I suppose this is another
piece of your esprit de corps. Well, there's to be no more of it."
When a chance offered the Shropshires were bartered for half their number
of R.W.F. from a neighboring division. As drafts came in we became less
English and more Welsh. One draft was purely Welsh from North Wales,
ordinarily the leanest recruiting district in the country; the men were
mostly clerks, small tradesmen and assistants, farmhands, schoolmasters
and such like. The worst element of all had been combed out of our Garrison
Battalion in Egypt. These men paraded protesting, one after another,
their unfitness for anything but garrison duty. In general fitness they
were well up to the average of the other drafts. Throughout the War
it was characteristic of men transferred from category units and subsidiary
services to resent re-posting to front-line service, and to scheme to
get away from it. I noted only two such re-postings who showed enough
keenness to earn promotion. An indication of the Home organization was
that the drafts said the food was better than in the camps at home.
Yet we had been having tinned food almost entirely since they joined
us, and only travelling cookers in which to prepare it.
[July 29th] Something of the French was to be seen at Bray. Their transport
is a mixed lot of Army and civilian vehicles. It looks simple compared
with ours, but very practical -- down to the bits of string with which
harness is held together. They work their German prisoners mighty close
to the shells. The German artillery shooting at the observation post
in the church steeple was good enough to flush the French observers.
Just behind the village the corn harvest was being hastened in.
[July 31st] On a route-march of 6 miles no one fell out! -- When the
death of Bowles and of Graves was reported through the Field Ambulance,
nine days ago, the customary letters were written to their kin. Now
Graves writes to the C.O. that the shock of learning how much he is
esteemed has recalled him from the grave, said that he has decided to
live for the sake of those whose warm feelings he has misunderstood.
[August 1st] In Amiens: a dusty drive with a merry party: a day off
for the C.O., who has got whiter about the gills with the coming of
each draft. Amiens must be the cheeriest provincial town in France:
it is stiff with Lines of Communication limpets; with officers who have
been in the soup and are for it again, with French troops, and with
perfumed "refugees" robed with disarming modesty. It is good
to see that the ancient rue des Corps nues sans Testes and the rue des
Trois-Cailloux have not been renamed after some modern politician or
writer of a day. We lunched at the Hotel du Rhin, where Gibbs, Thomas,
and Co., the official journalists attached to G.H.Q., live in state.
It was diverting to contrast the supercilious indifference with which
they jostled past the mere front-line officer, and frowned on his unwitting
approach to their reserved tables, with their alert deference when a
Red-tab entered the room. After Drinkwater had led the way into every
bar in or off the rue des Trois-Cailloux, and I had bought some things
for the Mess, he said there would "be no damned shopping next time"
he came to Amiens. I did not know until later that "Drinkwater"
was a nickname, I thought it a coincidence. Dinner at "The Godbert"
was good, even at the money, and decorous, although Colonel P., lamenting,
after the sweet, that he had not had any dressed lobster, did get down
on all-fours to stalk an unwatched dish on another table; and he devoured
it with help.
We must have owed the day's outing to some legerdemain by Yates's staff.
The O.C. Field Ambulance had to refuse the use of a car unless we found
the petrol. The time is supposedly past when a motor-transport man scoops
a hole in the ground and fills it with petrol every time he wants to
cook a stew, or wash a shirt, or heat shaving water. Petrol is rationed,
and car journeys are logged. Since there is no aerodrome near to spare
a few tins, Yates was consulted; as usual he said, "It can't be
done". Next morning, however, he mentioned, in the course of his
official talk after returning from Refilling Point, that "there
are two tins of petrol round at my place". In time, as scraps of
talk were pieced together, it was learned that the Field Ambulance Quartermaster
counted on the roadside the twenty tins of petrol he had indented for;
turning about to check his count he made the number eighteen, and no
subsequent recount made it more, nor could he or Supplies explain the
discrepancy. His C.O. always said he had a "very simple Quartermaster".
[August 2nd] Dolling rejoined from hospital; one good draft anyhow.
[August 4th] Thanks to Division and the C.O. I am one of 5 battalion
officers sent by car for a few hours at the sea. We started at 5 in
the morning and ran through Amiens, Picquigny, Abbeville, the lower
Somme valley and St. Valery to Cayeux, a fourth-rate holiday resort.
The sun beamed on us all the time.
[August 5th] The night air is getting nippy. The Somme at Cayeux has
not the scenic interest of the Canche at Etaples. Returning, we broke
the journey at Abbeville to have a look at St. Wolfram's.
From time to time stories get about of somebody's darling being kept
in cotton-wool when a unit is in action. Of one in whom a Higher Command
had been induced to take an interest, and convey it to his C.O., is
this note: his C.O. got a telegram -- "Has my poor nephew come
through all right?" It wasn't for his safety that her "poor
nephew" had been left out on kit-guard.
A remark by one of our artillery subalterns explains some erratic shooting:
"If we fire over you, God help you; we've only one trained gunner
per gun left." Of one group in Caterpillar Wood 75 per cent. became
casualties. In our recent operations the 19th Brigade had heavier losses
than the 98th or 100th. (The 51st Division came out of High Wood with
only two-fifths of the 33rd Division's losses).
Some of our Old Sweats have been returned by the 10th Battalion to
which they had been posted. They were such a nuisance, there being neither
company officers nor N.C.O.s who could handle them, that they were gifted
to us. The Old Lot in the area have been doing well; between the fleecing
of drafts at "Crown and Anchor", and the gleanings of the
battle-field, they have lined their pockets.
Army's verdict is for Division: Corps has been strafed for the High
Wood mess. It is just: the fault began at Corps. But the feeling in
every H.Q. in the Division is of remand on probation, not acquittal,
and that Corps will have the G.O.C. fired yet. The Division is returning
to the line with every Brigadier and O.C. on tenterhooks lest he be
made the scapegoat of the man above him.
[August 6th] We marched at 10 in the morning to the hillside behind
Bécordel, and bivouacked. Report says that 9,000 horses and mules
water at Bécordel and 17,000 at Méaulte: immense, if true.
For most of a week we were there the weather was broiling.
[August 10th] One wet night was followed by a dull day, and an inactive
front: fortunate, for the King was about. On most days a time of drum-fire
suggested a local attack on this unstable front.
The Staff Captain, a near relative of the Army Member of the Canteen
Board, was with the G.O.C. when our prices were asked about. We sell
"Gaspers" at 30 centimes, taking the full trading profit;
the Expeditionary Force Canteen charge is half a franc, and the Church
Army Huts one franc, for the same packet; their prices up here for other
articles are likewise extortionate. There had been questions in Parliament
because of an outcry at E.F.C. prices, which were thereupon reduced.
Training continued, and recreational training was added to supple unused
muscles. It was surprising how few of the drafts, whether townsmen or
country-bred, even the young, could clear a series of 20-inch hurdles:
more surprising that some of the young officers failed, one a Sandhurst
boy. Our awkwardest recruits were coming on, but some of our number
had taken an active dislike to the outlook. A stalwart, self-assured
boy, proud of the full rank he was given at home, pleaded his youth,
and sulked until his mother's proof that he is only seventeen arrived.
Another model of robust health, who had tried hard to get away, paraded
before the C.O. "It's no use reporting sick," he protested,
"you know what the doctor is." "We have a cheerful time
in store," Higginson wrote to Blair, "we are going in with
about 40 of the Béthune men per company" [B had less than
20], "the others are recruits, and the proportion of officer recruits
is much the same."
[August 13th] In the dark of morning a short move was made to Fricourt
Wood. We reported the outgoing unit for leaving filthy lines. At the
close of the ensuing correspondence the two C.Os. were not on speaking
terms. The German gunners have made our last month's bivouac unoccupiable;
they have many more guns: their infantry is well wired in. -- Summoned
to attend the Brigadier: found him a self-willed patient. The German
dug-out in the village, which Brigade occupies, is a three-storied,
many-roomed dwelling underground, with heating and sanitary arrangements;
its electric lighting has ceased to work.
[August 16th] Moody is back: another asset. A German airman he met
in hospital at Rouen said their game is up, Austria has let them down,
but they will fight to the end: he was quite ignorant of our side of
things, thought our Navy was scuppered at Jutland.
[August 17th] A German plane, coming out of a cloud, found one of ours
on top of him; about a dozen shots had been fired when the German turned
on his side and planed down behind us ablaze, like a comet. It was a
fine sight against a deep blue sky and great cumulus cloud, but terrible
to think about if the pilot wasn't shot dead.
For six days we found large working-parties to dig a communication
trench to High Wood, and to carry from the Bazentin Dumps. They came
in for enough shelling to light up the picture of "shell-shocked",
and "gassed", for which two years of lurid journalese in the
home papers had prepared the minds of the drafts; so the Dressing Station
nearby had many importunate applicants for admission. After three weeks
of ideal camping conditions the weather had broken, and the drafts were
having to make their first crude attempts to get themselves some shelter
and comfort.
[August 18th] Another chilly night, and noisy. A gray morning broke.
fine. More noise from 11 till noon. 2.45 was zero for a push through
Wood Lane and High Wood by the 100th and 98th Brigades while demonstrations
were made on the right and left. The gun-fire was over in little more
than an hour. Through it all the Band of the 6th Welsh Pioneers practiced:
it's a good Band, and plays good music of the "popular" kind:
a great din of guns made the strangest of obbligatos. We had rumors
of success everywhere. There appeared to be a local counter-attack,
or renewed attack, of short duration about 6 o'clock. At 7.30 we heard
that "nothing has been gained," that "the situation is
obscure." A warning order for us followed. We moved forward and,
after many wearisome halts, arrived in the dark on the Longueval-Bazentin
road below High Wood, and hung about.
[August19th] When day was breaking we resumed movement, still more
wearisome; through a communication trench near Crucifix Corner. We were
foodless and sleepless. A few widely dispersed shells came over at intervals,
as from one howitzer firing at random. Drafts filtered to the tail of
the Battalion, persuaded they were "shell-shocked," and formed
a little party who would not be convinced by gentle suasion alone that
the burst of a shell 100 yards off would not be taken as proof of shell-shock.
At last they rejoined their Companies, reluctantly but with heads fairly
erect. We relieved the 2nd Argylls. Yesterday they lost 180 men out
of 400. High Wood had broken another of several attacks since July 20th.
B, C, and D Companies hold a trench about 100 yards from the Germans,
A is again in support. In the autumn heat the air is fouled with the
smell of innumerable dead so lightly covered that in unsuspected, though
extensive, places one's tread disturbing the surface uncovers them,
or swarms of maggots show what one is seated near. An added smell was
from charred wood, for an attempt had been made to burn the enemy out
by projecting wads of ignited oily rag from old oil-drums converted
into mortars. Most of these had been smashed by the bad shooting of
our own heavies. And an attempt to sap across No Man's Land by a mole,
driven by a water-ram, had resulted in the blowing of a gap in our own
line, which gave the German snipers targets until we repaired it. In
the morning a shell killed the R.A.M.C. Orderly attached to infantry
aid-posts in those days. The day was quiet on the whole. In the late
evening the German field-guns and 4.2 howitzers plastered the support
and H.Q. position along the south-west border of the Wood. An enemy
attack seemed the likeliest explanation, so the support line wondered
whether our drafts from the front or the Germans would be the first
to leap through the. beech hedge on to it. After the strafe ended the
German gunners continued to be offensive spasmodically. They frustrated
two attempts at H.Q. to cook a dinner, by putting shells into the cookhouse
and upsetting the pots; they swept our rustic Mess of its contents a
moment after we had gone out of it; a shell burst on a Sapper who took
a seat from which I had just risen to attend to the trench-mortar team,
of whom a shell had killed 5 and wounded 2. When it became dark Radford
took out a small patrol from D Company; he found the German trench stiff
with men, and No Man's Land a tangle of fallen branches and trees that
made movement both difficult and noisy.
The C.O. had no news from the front until routine reports came in,
so there was nothing after all to be anxious about. There were 6 casualties
in the three front Companies in the twenty-four hours, and two dozen
in H.Q. and A Company in that lively hour. Two Companies mentioned the
shelling in rear, and quiet where were. One Company's report that 'an
enemy bombing attack had been broken up' was received with unquestioning
thankfulness and passed on to Brigade. Since only Orderly Room knew
the contents of these reports the rest of us suspected Brigade or Division
of some invention when G.H.Q.'s daily summary was published: "quiet
on the British Front except in High Wood where an attack by the enemy
was driven off", it said in effect. In was a phantom attack. The
Company Commander saw it in the smoke-wreaths of a guttering candle
in his shelter. The reality may be described in two scenes. The Company
Subaltern on Duty was feeling none too sure of himself as the stream
of shells swished overhead and burst behind, for it was his first hours
in a trench, so he was immensely heartened by the sight of his C.S.M.,
Dealing, leaning at ease over the parapet and looking round. "See
anything, Sergeant-Major?" he asked with what unconcern he could
put into his voice. "It appears to me, sir, that there's sweet
damn-all." And Dealing found a well-meaning young draft sitting
on the floor of the trench, zealously firing his rifle skywards. "Indirect
fire on Bapaume! Indirect fire on Bapaume!" was Dealing's rebuke,
for sergeants rule by sarcasm. Never can there have been an Army without
its Falstaffs and its Pistols. During the War some were hit, many were
"invalided with rheumatism", others were sent to jobs by a
tactful C.O. Some breathed life enough into their men in buckram to
get away with a decoration, and some did earn one; not a few got promotion,
which might be repeated, at home or in some eddy overseas.
[August 20th] In the morning Dolling and his C.S.M. were killed by
a shell : a great loss. In the afternoon a few of us watched a 1st Division
battalion scrambling up the slope beyond the Flers road; the Germans,
after failing to outflank them, bolted over the crest. It was a good
little surprise rush, though checked by our guns firing short.
Since our Division has not yet made any progress this tour the G.O.C.
is pressing, and the Brigadier very pressing, to "do something".
D Company is for it tonight. All arrangements have been made behind
by some person or persons unknown to us. Sketchy is not the word for
the Order. There is no word one dare utter of the prospects. I went
with the C.O. to see our 4.5's register. We thought their observer uncommonly
easily satisfied. At zero his battery fired without attracting much
attention from those most interested, and no one heard anything of the
trench-mortar fire. It was possible that the sounds were drowned by
the clatter of arms and equipment in tremulous hands, which someone
likened to "a runaway tinker's cart". Anyhow, the senseless
scheme of an attack in a thicket after dark by tyros was a washout from
the start; the men didn't follow their officers out of the trench.
[August 21st] Wilson, Dolling's successor as O.C. B Company has been
killed at the same place. Our 13-pounders persistently fire short on
our right, in contrast to the German guns which we see fire with great
accuracy close in front of their own line. -- The creeping barrage has
been revised; the lifts are to be 50 yards per minute. The where and
length of pauses matter more. -- An Engineer specialist came to prospect
the use of a smoke-screen: the prevailing wind is contrary. -- Division
and Brigade are calling for skilled patrolling and exact observation.
The fun of it is that the trained Scouts of Brigade's original battalions
have been kept at Brigade, doing only menial jobs for close on two years,
and "can't be spared". No one from the Staff has come to examine
the position in our time. Once the Brigadier did come -- and go after
a hasty look at it.
"'Sunny Jim' was the name by which the troops best knew Private
Edge of B Company. He was a bit on the weak sire, although he had stuck
all the marching of the Retreat, and ordinary duty afterward s until
the M.O. gave him a job on the Canteen Staff. High Wood and the ground
in rear was an unhealthy place in August 1916. One morning Sunny Jim
appeared. He had no equipment but a pack slung by the supporting straps.
'What do you want?', I asked. Edge had a slight impediment in his speech.
"I fort the boys would want some sigawettes, so I've bwought some
up.' He had come about 7 miles because he 'fort the boys wanted cigawettes.'
He went round the Companies, sold his stock, and went off again as if
it were nothing out of the ordinary." (Boreham).
All the Companies are rattled. The Old Lot show it too, although there
are some splendid stoics. This morning three of B, all good men, came
and begged to be sent to the Transport for a rest: they said that they
could not stand being in with the drafts any longer. One fell on his
knees and wept when told that they must stick it and show a good example,
but they were taken for a few hours rest to a trench where I had slept.
Going later to see how they were I found them gone: found too that the
trench was floored with very lightly covered dead. I had said it was
warm and soft to lie in. When next we met their smile of greeting was
sickly.
At midnight the Germans had the wind up. They put up flares all round;
threw out their defensive screen of bombers, and dropped
[August 22nd] all their barrages. At 5 a.m. we were relieved, and went
into support at Crucifix Corner. Ever afterwards these three days were
spoken of by the experienced officers, N.C.Os. and others as "a
nightmare". Our casualties for the tour were upwards of 70. The
German is master of the air here at present, he flies all over us, scatters
our scouts, and slips away from our fighters. These were the days of
the supremacy of the Fokker monoplane.
[August 24th] There was a tremendous din for two hours in the early
morning. The 100th Brigade made some progress between Delville and High
Woods: we got the overspill of the shelling. We were often under dispersed
shelling during four days of finding day and night working-parties.
A dud made a trench cave in on two men; although dug out ever so quickly
they were dead. -- Some of our Old Lot were offered an extra tot of
rum to bury a more than commonly unburied body. After dark they had
a funeral, and got the rum. In daylight next morning another squad earned
the rum.
[August 26th] At 4 a.m. we returned to High Wood through a barrage,
slight but unpleasant enough; there was one casualty; only two of the
drafts jibbed. A suggestion by the C.O. to make a dash at the flanks
and bomb in was vetoed by Brigade, where he is not persona grata. Anyhow,
our Division is marking time; High Wood is to give luster to another.
Untaught by what happened eight days ago when the propulsion of end-to-end
tubes charged with ammonal, the leading tube shod with a mole, was tried
as a means of blowing communications to the German line. Someone has
six moles at work. Our G.S.O.1 came and asked to see them, giving a
long technical name in which "hydraulic", was the clue; he
looked more dangerous than peeved at a scoffing response, "Oh,
you mean the Heath Robinson stunt." None of us pedestrians understands
how a mole can be expected to keep direction among the roots of even
such shallow-rooted trees as beeches. Sure enough, it was not long before
a sentry was seen, standing spell-bound by an object in front of his
post; like a fabulous monster it rose out of the earth jerking and waggling.
It was a dislocated mole. (I never heard of the mole being used at the
front in soil where it might have been practicable.) Flame projectors
and other gadgets are on the ground to ensure a spectacular capture
of the Wood by the 1st Division. A current view among those who knew
the G.O.C. 1st Division as Brigadier in the 33rd is that if hot air
be the further means to success he has a never-failing supply in himself.
(The attack was made a week later. Again the "pipe-pushers"
tore gaps only in our own line; and again the Germans had the laugh
at the oil-rags; this time a Stokes mortar fired short, lighting them
too soon. The rest was tragedy. High Wood was never captured by assault
except on July 20th. In the second half of September an attack on a
wide front, led by caterpillar tanks armed with guns, making their first
appearance, carried the line beyond Flers on both sides of the Wood;
the German garrison was cut off from support or escape, and surrendered
to the Civil Service Rifles.)
[August 27th] Relieved by the 1st Black Watch, we withdrew to Fricourt
Wood in rain. The mud is inches deep in what was a pleasant sylvan retreat
nine days ago.
[August 28th] The Gazette with the Givenchy decorations is out. That
sort of list always has surprises for those who saw most of the Show;
not infrequently, the most deserving and the undeserving are rewarded
equally. Some details of a shelling of Béthune have reached us.
Favorite haunts are said to be holed and tenantless, and some familiar
inhabitants are casualties; the proprietor of The Globe is one of them.
[August 29th] At 6 a.m., we moved to a trench in front of Montauban;
the trench, in its first state, was a ditch. We are lent to the 98th
Brigade who nibble at Wood Line. A bit for C Company has been cancelled
owing to the heavy rain. Operations are at a standstill; our working-parties
come back through the mud at one mile an hour. Some of the drafts are
singing, others have had to be sent to the Transport for shelter and
rest.
(1) "Graves":
Robert Graves. The story of Graves' injury is discussed in greater detail
by Graves himself in his Goodbye to All
That.
[preface] [chapter 9] [chapter
10] [chapter 11]